Skip to content

Inside Skull and Bones: Yale’s Elite Secret Brotherhood

Skull and Bones Society

Table of Contents

The complete history, famous members, and enduring mysteries of America’s most notorious collegiate society

What Is the Skull and Bones Society?

The Skull and Bones society stands as America’s most notorious collegiate secret organization, shrouded in mystery since its founding at Yale University in 1832. For nearly two centuries, this exclusive brotherhood has captivated public imagination through its unique combination of secrecy, ritual, and extraordinary influence.

Known formally as “The Order of Skull and Bones” and informally as “The Order” or “The Brotherhood,” this secret society is instantly recognizable by its iconic emblem—a skull and crossbones accompanied by the number “322.” According to society lore, this number references the death of Greek orator Demosthenes in 322 BCE, symbolizing the end of Athenian democracy and perhaps hinting at the society’s philosophical underpinnings.

What distinguishes Skull and Bones from typical college fraternities is its remarkable concentration of power, with members historically occupying positions at the highest levels of American government, finance, media, intelligence services, and education. The society selects only 15 new Yale seniors annually, creating an extremely exclusive membership that contributes to its mystique and perceived influence.

The Secret Origins of Yale’s Most Powerful Society

The Skull and Bones society was established in December 1832 by Yale senior William Huntington Russell, alongside Alphonso Taft (father of future President William Howard Taft). Russell, having recently returned from studies in Germany, was reportedly inspired by German student organizations—particularly the “Burschenschaften” movement with its emphasis on philosophical debate, symbolic rituals, and lifelong brotherhood bonds.

Originally named “The Eulogian Club” before adopting its more infamous moniker, the society was founded with a specific mission: to create an elite network of Yale students united by loyalty, discretion, and mutual advancement. From its inception, the society maintained strict secrecy about its internal operations while simultaneously cultivating an aura of prestige and influence.

The Skull and Bones selection process has evolved significantly throughout its history:

  • 1830s-1940s: Exclusively white Protestant males from elite backgrounds
  • 1950s-1960s: Gradual inclusion of Catholic and Jewish students
  • 1991: First admission of women after significant internal controversy
  • Modern era: Increased diversity, though still highly selective and prestige-oriented

Prominent Skull and Bones Members Throughout History

The society’s membership roster reads like a who’s who of American power and influence across generations:

U.S. Presidents
William Howard Taft (1878)
27th President and later Chief Justice of the Supreme Court
U.S. Presidents
George H.W. Bush (1948)
41st President, former CIA Director, Vice President
U.S. Presidents
George W. Bush (1968)
43rd President, former Texas Governor
Political Figures
John Kerry (1966)
Secretary of State, Presidential candidate, Senator
Political Figures
McGeorge Bundy (1940)
National Security Advisor to Kennedy and Johnson
Business Leaders
Frederick W. Smith (1966)
Founder and CEO of FedEx
Business Leaders
Stephen A. Schwarzman (1969)
Co-founder of Blackstone Group, major philanthropist
Media&Literature
William F. Buckley Jr. (1950)
National Review founder, conservative intellectual

This extraordinary concentration of power within a single collegiate society has fueled both legitimate inquiries and unfounded conspiracy theories about the organization’s influence on American policy and global affairs throughout its nearly 200-year history.

Inside “The Tomb”: The Enigmatic Headquarters of Skull and Bones

The physical hub of the Skull and Bones society is its headquarters building, known universally as “The Tomb.” Located at 64 High Street on Yale’s campus, this imposing sandstone structure stands as one of the university’s most recognizable and mysterious landmarks since its construction in 1856.

The Tomb’s architecture deliberately evokes secrecy and power through its windowless façade, massive iron doors, and imposing presence. The building has been expanded several times over its history, now encompassing approximately 16,000 square feet of interior space specifically designed for the society’s secret activities.

Architectural Features

  • 🏛️ Architectural Influence
    Combines Egyptian, Greco-Roman, and Gothic elements in a fortress-like design meant to intimidate and intrigue.
  • 🚪 Entry Points
    Features massive iron doors with elaborate locking mechanisms and reportedly has underground access tunnels connecting to other Yale buildings.
  • 🔍 Exterior Design
    No windows on street-facing walls, several security cameras, and a courtyard completely hidden from public view.

Reported Interior Spaces

  • 🏮 The Main Hall
    A two-story meeting chamber with ritualistic layout, special seating arrangements, and society symbols throughout.
  • 📚 Library& Archives
    Contains member histories, society documents, and reportedly various artifacts collected throughout the society’s existence.
  • 🍽️ Dining Hall
    Where members share ritual meals and engage in traditional society conversations and debates.
  • 💀 The Crypt
    A lower-level room reported to house various skulls, bones, and ceremonial items used in society rituals.

Despite intense public curiosity, very few non-members have ever entered The Tomb, contributing to the mystique surrounding the Yale Skull and Bones society. Yale campus tours specifically avoid this building, and university officials generally decline to discuss it in official capacities.

Secret Rituals and Ceremonies of the Order

The rituals of the Skull and Bones society remain among its most closely guarded secrets. While members take oaths of silence, various accounts from former members, witnesses, and historical documents have provided glimpses into the organization’s ceremonial practices.

The Selection Process: “Tapping”

Membership begins with “tapping”—the society’s distinctive selection protocol. Occurring each April, current Bonesmen physically tap chosen juniors on the shoulder and offer the cryptic invitation: “Skull and Bones: Do you accept?” The selected student must provide an immediate answer, with acceptance binding them to secrecy and participation in all society activities.

The tapping process has evolved from an originally public campus ceremony to a more discreet approach, though the fundamental ritual remains unchanged after nearly two centuries.

Initiation Ceremonies

Based on multiple accounts, the Skull and Bones initiation ritual includes several distinct elements that blend theatrical, psychological, and traditional components:

  • ⚰️ The Coffin Ritual
    Initiates reportedly lie in a coffin and recount their personal and sexual histories to other members—a ritual called “connubial bliss.”
  • 🔄 Symbolic Rebirth
    Various accounts describe a mock birth ceremony where initiates emerge from a coffin, symbolizing their rebirth as Bonesmen.
  • 💀 Skeletal Encounter
    Initiates allegedly must kiss a skull during ceremonies—claimed by some to be that of Native American leader Geronimo, which prompted a 2009 lawsuit.
  • 📜 Oath Taking
    Members swear lifelong loyalty oaths to the society and its members, pledging secrecy about all internal activities.
  • 🎭 New Identity
    Each new member receives a ritual name or identity used within society meetings and communications.
  • 🧠 Psychological Elements
    Initiation reportedly includes psychological techniques designed to create strong emotional bonds between members.

Ongoing Meeting Traditions

Once initiated, Bonesmen participate in regular meetings and activities throughout their senior year:

  • 📅 Twice-Weekly Gatherings
    Members meet every Thursday and Sunday evening for discussions, rituals, and society business.
  • 💬 Structured Debates
    Sessions reportedly include formal debates on philosophical, political, and ethical topics, with specific society protocols governing these discussions.
  • 👥 Member Presentations
    Each Bonesman delivers autobiographical presentations to the group throughout the year, building deeper connections between members.

These rituals serve multiple purposes within the Skull and Bones organization: they build intense loyalty between members, reinforce the society’s exclusivity, and create shared experiences that bond members across generations.

The Real Power& Influence Networks of Yale’s Elite Brotherhood

Beyond its secretive rituals, the true significance of the Skull and Bones society lies in its remarkable concentration of power and influence. The society’s members have historically occupied key positions throughout American institutions, creating a network effect that continues to benefit new generations of Bonesmen.

Professional Network Benefits

  • 👔 Career Advancement
    Members gain access to exclusive job opportunities and accelerated promotion paths across industries.
  • 💰 Financial Support
    The society reportedly maintains investment funds and support mechanisms for members’ ventures.
  • 🔑 Institutional Access
    Members gain introductions to key decision-makers in politics, finance, media, and academia.

Spheres of Influence

  • 🏛️ Government& Politics
    The 2004 presidential election featured Bonesmen as both major candidates (Bush and Kerry), highlighting the society’s political reach.
  • 🏦 Wall Street& Finance
    Members occupy leadership positions at major investment banks, hedge funds, private equity firms, and financial regulatory bodies.
  • 🎓 Academia& Education
    Many members return to elite universities as administrators, professors, and trustees, shaping educational institutions.

The society’s influence extends beyond individual members to create powerful intergenerational bonds. Senior Bonesmen often serve as mentors and sponsors for junior members, reinforcing institutional connections across decades and administrations.

Historian and journalist Alexandra Robbins, who extensively researched the Skull and Bones secret society for her book “Secrets of the Tomb,” concluded: “They do have certain values that they wish to spread throughout society. That’s not the same as saying that they’re trying to rule the world or control the world.”

Skull and Bones: Separating Conspiracy Theories from Reality

Few organizations have inspired as many conspiracy theories as the Skull and Bones society. The combination of secrecy, powerful members, and ritualistic practices creates a perfect environment for speculation and misinformation. To understand the true nature of this Yale brotherhood, it’s essential to separate documented facts from unfounded claims.

Common Conspiracy Claims Evidence-Based Reality
The society controls world events and manipulates global politics Members hold influential positions, but no evidence supports coordinated global manipulation
Skull and Bones is directly connected to the Illuminati No credible historical evidence links the two organizations
The society orchestrated major historical events like the JFK assassination Claims rely on circumstantial connections rather than substantive evidence
The society operates as a shadow government with control over the CIA While members have served in intelligence roles, no evidence shows organizational control
The group’s treasury holds billions in assets that influence global markets The society has financial resources, but claims of market-moving wealth are unsubstantiated

Most serious researchers who have investigated the Yale Skull and Bones organization conclude that its primary function is networking and relationship building rather than global conspiracy. Its influence stems from the connections between members who individually attain positions of power, not from coordinated control of world events.

As former Washington Post journalist Alexandra Robbins concluded after extensive research: “Are they a global conspiracy? No. Do they have undue influence? Yes. Are they worth paying attention to? Absolutely.”

The Modern Skull and Bones Society: Still Relevant Today?

Despite being nearly two centuries old, the Skull and Bones society continues to operate at Yale University, selecting 15 new members annually. However, the organization has evolved significantly in recent decades to adapt to changing social norms and increased public scrutiny.

Key Modern Developments

  • Gender Integration (1991)

    After significant controversy and alumni opposition, women were first admitted in 1991, fundamentally changing the society’s character.

  • Increased Diversity

    Modern cohorts reflect greater racial, ethnic, socioeconomic, and international diversity than historical membership.

  • University Relationship

    Yale’s administration now maintains more oversight of the society than in previous eras, requiring compliance with university policies.

Challenges in the Digital Era

  • Information Leaks

    Smartphones and social media have made maintaining strict secrecy increasingly difficult, with occasional photos and details emerging online.

  • Changed Campus Culture

    Today’s Yale students often view traditional societies with more skepticism, though Skull and Bones still attracts prominent campus leaders.

  • Institutional Competition

    New professional networks, online platforms, and career development resources have reduced the society’s monopoly on elite connections.

According to recent Yale graduates and campus observers, the Skull and Bones organization today functions more as a prestigious leadership society and networking opportunity than the shadowy power broker of popular imagination. While its historical significance and wealthy alumni network ensure ongoing relevance, its mystique has diminished somewhat in the information age.

Frequently Asked Questions About the Skull and Bones Society

How does someone get selected for the Skull and Bones society?
Selection is based on a combination of campus leadership positions, academic achievement, family connections, athletic prominence, and diverse perspectives. Each existing Bones class selects the next cohort through a consensus process. While historically dominated by legacy connections, modern selection places greater emphasis on campus influence and diverse backgrounds.
What actually happens during Skull and Bones meetings?
According to various accounts from former members, meetings typically include ceremonial elements, discussions on philosophical and political topics, sharing of personal information (the “connubial bliss” sessions), and networking activities. The society maintains traditions dating back to the 1830s, though these have evolved over time. Regular meetings occur twice weekly throughout the members’ senior year.
Does the Skull and Bones society control world events?
No credible evidence supports claims that Skull and Bones orchestrates global events as an organization. However, the concentration of members in positions of influence does create informal networks that can impact decision-making in business, politics, and other fields. The society functions more as a networking organization than a coordinated global conspiracy.
Is it true that Skull and Bones stole Geronimo’s skull?
This claim stems from a 1918 letter from Winter Mead (a Bonesman) suggesting that members took “the skull of Geronimo the terrible” from his grave. In 2009, Geronimo’s descendants filed a lawsuit over these claims, but the case was dismissed. Yale and the society deny possessing the skull, and forensic evidence suggests Geronimo’s remains were likely undisturbed. However, the society does allegedly possess various other skulls and bones used in ceremonies.
How much wealth and financial power does the society control?
While the society itself maintains assets including its headquarters building and some endowment funds, its financial power comes primarily through its member network rather than direct institutional control. Individual Bonesmen have achieved significant wealth in finance, industry, and other sectors, but claims of the society controlling trillions in assets or manipulating global markets lack substantiation.
How has the Skull and Bones society changed in modern times?
Significant modern changes include: gender integration (women admitted since 1991), increased racial and socioeconomic diversity, reduced emphasis on legacy admissions, greater university oversight, adaptation to digital-age scrutiny, and evolving campus perceptions. While maintaining its core traditions, the society has needed to adapt to contemporary social norms and expectations.

The Skull and Bones secret society remains a fascinating intersection of American history, power, privilege, and mythology. While its influence has undoubtedly shaped aspects of American institutional development, particularly in the late 19th and 20th centuries, many popular perceptions of the society blend fact with fiction.

As American society continues to evolve toward greater transparency and diverse leadership, the future of this distinctive Yale institution will depend on its ability to balance tradition with adaptation to changing social expectations. What seems certain is that as long as it continues to operate, Skull and Bones will remain an object of fascination, speculation, and study for those interested in the nature of power, privilege, and secrecy in American life.

About This Comprehensive Guide
This definitive exploration of the Skull and Bones society was meticulously researched using publicly available information, historical records, academic sources, and interviews with historians specializing in American secret societies and Yale University traditions. Last updated November 2023 to include the most current information about this historic institution.
The secret of Skyll and Bones Secret Society